Correspondence with Atlantic Monthly Editor Robert Manning on "The Failure of Black Separatism" and Labor Unions

This correspondence is from September 16 - December 22, 1969.

Description
This four-letter editorial exchange between Bayard Rustin and Atlantic Monthly Editor-in-Chief Robert Manning reveals the behind-the-scenes publishing story of Rustin's famous essay "The Failure of Black Separatism" and his follow-up work on organized labor. In his September 16, 1969 letter, Manning responds to an early draft of Rustin's essay on the Black protest movement. Praising Theodore Draper's recent critique of Black nationalism, Manning urges Rustin to narrow his focus and examine a single urgent question in greater depth: whether American labor unions genuinely help or hinder Black workers. Manning argues that Rustin dismissed critics of union racism and conservatism too quickly, pressing him to write a harder-hitting piece on what unions actually do for trained and untrained Black laborers. On October 9, Rustin replies that he is eager to write the labor article and hopes to meet with Manning upon returning from a trip to Tunis.

However, a miscommunication soon sparked sharp editorial friction. On December 16, 1969, Manning writes to express his surprise and disappointment upon learning that Rustin's manuscript on Black separatism was about to appear in rival Harper's Magazine (published in January 1970 as "The Failure of Black Separatism"), noting that he had held a prime winter slot for it at The Atlantic. In his December 22 reply, Rustin clears up the misunderstanding, explaining that he believed The Atlantic had rejected the separatism manuscript in favor of a completely different article focused strictly on Black people and the trade union movement. Assuring Manning that he is actively gathering material for the union essay—which was later published in The Atlantic in May 1971 as "The Blacks and the Unions"—Rustin promises to call as soon as he returns from Morocco in January 1970.

Historical Context

In the late 1960s, major national magazines like Harper's, The Atlantic Monthly, and Commentary served as central battlegrounds for intellectual debates over the future of the civil rights movement. As urban riots, campus takeovers, and Black Power rhetoric dominated the news, editors sought leading voices who could explain the growing divide between integrationists and Black nationalists. At the same time, fierce public clashes over affirmative action in the building trades and the 1968 New York City teachers' strike had strained relations between civil rights groups and organized labor, leading many white liberals to view trade unions as conservative obstacles to racial progress.

Within this charged media climate, Rustin used major magazine essays to defend the alliance between Black workers and the AFL-CIO while challenging both Black separatists and anti-union liberals. This correspondence captures how Rustin navigated top editorial gatekeepers to place his two defining essays of the era—sending his broadside against separatism to Harper's while working with Robert Manning to craft a dedicated, data-driven defense of unionism for The Atlantic.


Manning, Robert, and Bayard Rustin. Editorial Correspondence Regarding "The Failure of Black Separatism" and Labor Essays, September 16 – December 22, 1969.