Rustin’s Humanist article argues that Eldridge Cleaver’s return from exile matters because he came home with a transformed, deeply democratic politics, rejecting authoritarianism after firsthand experience and embracing “radical democracy” over violent revolution. Rustin presents Cleaver as a rare figure willing to admit past errors, defend American democratic principles without denying their flaws, and challenge the left to take democracy, and Cleaver’s right to a fair trial, seriously.