Rustin announced the Eldridge Cleaver Defense Fund by emphasizing that, despite their past political opposition, he was defending Cleaver’s right to a fair trial, not his past actions. He highlighted Cleaver’s political maturation, the abandonment and distortion by former allies and the media, and argued that Cleaver’s hard-won critique of totalitarianism made him a uniquely credible voice on the value of democratic reform.
Bayard Rustin's “Eldridge Cleaver and the Democratic Idea”: Reclaiming Democracy after the Ruins of Revolution
Rustin’s Humanist article argues that Eldridge Cleaver’s return from exile matters because he came home with a transformed, deeply democratic politics, rejecting authoritarianism after firsthand experience and embracing “radical democracy” over violent revolution. Rustin presents Cleaver as a rare figure willing to admit past errors, defend American democratic principles without denying their flaws, and challenge the left to take democracy, and Cleaver’s right to a fair trial, seriously.
Bayard Rustin's "The Transformation of Eldridge Cleaver": Analyzing the Making of a Revolutionary Myth
Eldridge Cleaver's "Why I Left the U.S. and Why I Am Returning": A Revolutionary's Reckoning with Democracy
Cleaver’s essay recounts how seven years in exile shattered his faith in authoritarian revolutionary ideals and led him to recognize the imperfect but real accountability mechanisms within American democracy. His experiences abroad, combined with Watergate and the Church Committee revelations, convinced him that the U.S. still allowed forms of dissent, scrutiny, and self-correction absent in the regimes he had fled.
