These correspondences are from October 29 and December 17, 1969.
Description
In this two-part exchange, Queensborough Community College history professor Herbert S. Parmet writes to Bayard Rustin on October 29, 1969, seeking insider facts for his upcoming book on the Eisenhower presidency regarding the May 17, 1957 "Prayer Pilgrimage for Freedom" in Washington, D.C. Parmet asks five direct questions: what Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. saw as the purpose of the event, why organizers chose a prayer pilgrimage rather than a traditional march on Washington, who the key planners were, and whether anyone in the Eisenhower Administration cooperated behind the scenes. Handwritten notes across Parmet's letter show Rustin's immediate, blunt reactions—jotting down "No cooperation / No acceptance / Ignored by the White House"—before sending his formal typed reply on December 17, 1969.
In his five-point response, Rustin sets the historical record straight on how the 1957 demonstration was organized. First, he clarifies that A. Philip Randolph—not Dr. King—originally conceived the Prayer Pilgrimage to draw national attention to racial terror in the South and rally support behind the Montgomery Bus Boycott. Second, Rustin explains that calling the gathering a "Prayer Pilgrimage" was a deliberate organizing tactic rather than a scaled-back march: because the Black church was the strongest protest institution in 1957 and King's primary network consisted of clergy, framing the event around prayer was the most effective way to mobilize Northern Black ministers and their congregations. Third, Rustin names the five core architects who shaped the event: A. Philip Randolph, Reverend Thomas Kilgore, Reverend Fred L. Shuttlesworth, Martin Luther King Jr., and himself. Finally, Rustin states flatly that organizers had zero official or unofficial contact with the Eisenhower Administration, contrasting Eisenhower's total indifference with the active cooperation civil rights leaders later received from the Kennedy and Johnson Administrations.
Historical Context
Held on May 17, 1957—the third anniversary of the Supreme Court's Brown v. Board of Education school desegregation ruling—the Prayer Pilgrimage for Freedom brought roughly 25,000 demonstrators to the Lincoln Memorial. At the time, Southern states were waging "Massive Resistance" against school integration, Black voters across the Deep South remained violently disenfranchised, and the Civil Rights Act of 1957 was stalled in Congress. The event marked Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s first major address on a national stage following the Montgomery Bus Boycott, where he delivered his famous "Give Us the Ballot" speech and established himself alongside A. Philip Randolph as a national civil rights leader.
By late 1969, when historian Herbert S. Parmet contacted Rustin while researching Eisenhower and the American Crusades (published in 1972), scholars were beginning to write the first serious histories of the modern civil rights movement. Rustin's reply preserves crucial firsthand evidence of his behind-the-scenes role as chief logistical strategist—a role he repeated six years later at the 1963 March on Washington—while documenting the cold shoulder civil rights organizers faced from the White House during the 1950s.
Parmet, Herbert S., and Bayard Rustin. Correspondence Regarding the 1957 Prayer Pilgrimage for Freedom, October 29 – December 17, 1969.
